I think it might depend on the way that 2nd example is said. If they say it in a way that implies "you have been working too hard, so are imagining things" then that would definitely throw a wrench into things.
Even that, to me, is okay because it is what I’d say in real life. Which would allow my scene partner to then show me that it happened. I wouldn’t keep saying they are wrong and it couldn’t have happened, but I think it’s important to find a way to say we live in a regular world where that experience isn’t the norm
I see what you are saying. I agree. Used that way, it is a more complicated "wait, what?!". I guess I just worry about a newer improviser misunderstanding, and then they just keep holding onto this perspective that the person is just out of it the whole scene.
I think it might depend on the way that 2nd example is said. If they say it in a way that implies "you have been working too hard, so are imagining things" then that would definitely throw a wrench into things.
Even that, to me, is okay because it is what I’d say in real life. Which would allow my scene partner to then show me that it happened. I wouldn’t keep saying they are wrong and it couldn’t have happened, but I think it’s important to find a way to say we live in a regular world where that experience isn’t the norm
I see what you are saying. I agree. Used that way, it is a more complicated "wait, what?!". I guess I just worry about a newer improviser misunderstanding, and then they just keep holding onto this perspective that the person is just out of it the whole scene.